The World Science Summit '08

Right now I am reporting from the World Science Summit in the Low Library of Columbia University. This morning they have already awarded 3 brand new $1 million prizes called the Kavli prize. They have been given to top researchers for their discoveries in nanoscience, astrophysics and neuroscience.

Brian Greene and Michael Bloomberg have also given some great introductory remarks. And, finally, the panel that just spoke on "The Big, The Small and The Complex" has just spoken and included 3 Nobel Laureates along with NYU neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux.

What does this have to do with the craft of teaching? It is like being surrounded by movie stars for me. This is truly an infusion of excitement into my teaching life at a time in the year that otherwise would be occupied with thoughts of grading the students' last lab report of the year, cleaning up the room, equipment orders, evaluation and other year-end tasks.

Never underestimate the value of breaking out of your teaching routine to rub elbows with your field's glitterati.

The Value of Experience

"We live in a world that is information-rich but experience-poor."

This was a quotation from a friend of mine and I think it is right on. Check out the podcast I created in collaboration with my school which expands on the idea of experience as cornerstone of good teaching and learning.

Writing: how should it be graded?

"What we need to figure out is how to get the kids to write more, but grade less."

This was one of the opening lines an English teacher said to a group of us teachers gathered in the faculty room this morning. This might be the Holy Grail of not just English teachers but all teachers. I know as a science teacher I have thought the same thing with regard to lab reports.

Writing is not only a tool for communication but it is a tool for thinking and understanding.

There are a lot of questions that this brings up:

• What does the student gain from teachers commenting on their writing?
• Are there certain types of students who get more out of the comments than others?
• What is the place of peer editing?
• What are the other issues we should be looking at?
• How can we optimize our grading time and effort?
  

Teaching is a craft.

Before I was a teacher, I was an Outward Bound instructor. I led trips of various lengths: anywhere from a day to 3 weeks. I also worked with a wide variety of people: investment bankers and juvenile offenders, children of the affluent from all over America to children of the indigent in the South Bronx.

I had a chance to learn from the students on these courses, but I learned even more from the course directors and veteran instructors who trained me. One such person was David McGough. He was not only brilliant but, more importantly, he was wise. He was the first person to discuss teaching as a craft.

He chose to think of it as such because it was both an art and a science. There was a "right" way to structure a lesson in order for students to maximally retain the information. At least there were best practices that could be followed. A good teacher has to know, developmentally, where their students are at. That is science.

However, at least half of teaching is an art. It takes a tremendous amount of heart and soul. The stickiest parts of the process--beginnings, endings, misconceptions, disagreements and disconnections--require an artful touch. This is often where those with a strong socio-emotional intelligence excel.

I have to admit, part of me likes reinventing the wheel every year. It is too much work and an inefficient way to use one's time. I know. My wife certainly knows. She sees the same frustrating show every year. However, this process keeps it fresh for me. I suppose that is the art side of teaching in action, re-creation.

And, as much as I don't like to admit it, when it comes to designing my classes, re-creation is sometimes recreational.